Dispute On the Behalf of FiveBots

So to begin I will start off by saying why exactly I decided to look into this. Basically I was chilling on skype while preparing to start training on Runescape. Someone on my friends list sends a message to a bunch of people saying he was banned and seemed upset. I was bored so I wanted to look into a scam report. Maybe it was something interesting? Well, it involved a crap ton of accounts so I decided to look into it a bit more, because this kid seemed a little upset about it and is young (main reason I decided to look into it).

tl;dr: I just was bored so decided to look into it ^^^

Banned Member's Account: FiveBots

Scam Report: Here

Throughout this thread I am going to refer to FiveBots's Accounts as such and the other accounts not belonging to him as the "bad accounts."

So basically these are all of FiveBots's Accounts that he has had over the past:
The dates are the accounts creation dates.

Spoiler: Option

First Account - Australian Prod 11-29-2011
http://www.sythe.org/members/321077-australian-prod.html

Posted a Thread for His friend Rso6 (Related to who i am assuming is runescapeo6)
http://www.sythe.org/fire-cape-kiln...recaping-service-been-capeing-since-06-a.html

Second Account - Dylanisme (No Ip connection to Australian Prod) 6-10-2012
http://www.sythe.org/members/342651-dylanisme.html

Account was Hacked and decided to create a new account

Third Account - PartyNeon (IP as DylanisMe)
http://www.sythe.org/members/384759-partyneon.html

Banned due to having dylanisme being hacked

Fourth Account - Creativeneon
http://www.sythe.org/members/386137-creativeneon.html

Banned due to having dylanisme

This was all cleared by Roary here http://www.sythe.org/12443655-post3.html

Fifth Account - Fivebots (No Association with any other IPS) 6-24-2013
http://www.sythe.org/members/385522-fivebots.html

Wow lots of accounts for 1 person.

Now lets break just this part down. If we assume that Australian Prod is his first account, then all the other accounts are valid and are supported (Post from Roary Proof

Here are all of the accounts that are the r4 "bad account" guy:

Spoiler: Option

r4n6ee 6-23-2008 to (Last post 4-22-2012) 4-25-2011 r4 email obvi
http://www.sythe.org/members/161308-r4n6ee.html

runescapeo6 12-08-2008 to (Last Post 12-08-2009) 2-08-2011 r4n6ee email
http://www.sythe.org/members/185740-runescapeo6.html

onespec 1-25-2009 to (last post 8-23-2011) 8-24-2011 [email protected]
http://www.sythe.org/members/193106-onespec.html

Rs2Service 08-08-2009 to (last post 5-27-2011) 5-13-2012 [email protected] r4 email again!
http://www.sythe.org/members/219876-rs2service.html

r4n6e 12-31-2009 to (Last Post 4-16-2011) 12-07-2011 r4 email again!!!
http://www.sythe.org/members/235984-r4n6e.html

rodgod#12 4-14-2011 to (Last Post 5-15-2011) 5-24-2011 r4 email again!!!!
http://www.sythe.org/members/293108-rodgod-12.html

cgbeaver 5-14-2011 to (Last Post 5-16-2011) 5-23-2011 r4 email again!!!!
http://www.sythe.org/members/296463-cgbeaver.html

a5z 8-04-2011 to (Last Post 5-13-2012) 5-13-2012 rs2service
http://www.sythe.org/members/307297-a5z.html

JuicyJ 12-15-2011 to (Last Post 1-14-2012) 1-29-2012 rs2service email again!!!
http://www.sythe.org/members/322807-juicyj.html

ShazamRS 10-15-2011 to (Last Post 10-15-2011) 10-15-2011
http://www.sythe.org/members/315923-shazamrs.html

6rudge 5-22-2012 to (4-09-2013) 05-07-2013 r4 email again!!!!
http://www.sythe.org/members/340850-6rudge.html

Now the only thing that is connecting these accounts to the earlier accounts are Australian Prod. So I will mainly focus on this account.

How is Australian Prod associated with the other accounts which I will call the "bad accounts?"

The connecting point to the other accounts is a thread post that the Australian Prod posted on behalf of RSo6 (here. This post uses an email ([email protected]) that is a "bad account" (cgbeaver). Prod also posted a fire cape thread and account thread that is basically the same as a few other "bad accounts."

Concerns over the email
Prod uses an different email [email protected] just a few days before. Why the sudden change in emails?

The thread he creates is also titled "Rso6's Firecaping Service! Been capeing since 06'" Here. Why post a thread for someone else? Interesting...

So basically what happened is FiveBots's was unable to create his own account so he had a friend do it. This friend is the owner of all these bad accounts. Here is the IP search and his member number: 321077 use number here: http://www.sythe.org/userlookup.php

If you really look at the IP address you will notice changes where Prod is on the "same ip" as other "bad accounts" (look how Prod is on the same time as a5z, JuicyJ, 6rudge). However, there are a few times where Prod is not.

This raised the question as to maybe this friend has been using the account that he help make for Fivebot's.

Therefore, I feel like it would be fair if you could see the specific IP changes in posts. I feel like it would be worthwhile to compare the specific post IP's in this list of posts: Here​

The accounts that need to be compared to Prod are: (
r4n6ee All Posts
a5z All Posts
Juicyj All Posts
6rudge All Posts

All these accounts had activity during the time of Prod's use.

I also feel it would be important to also compare the IP's between Fivebots's posts during the activity of other "bad accounts." The above 4 are also the only ones active during Fivebots's activity. Also if you look at the posting history of the "bad accounts" there is constant advertisement for their 130's account, yet there is nothing of the sort for Fivebot.

I am pretty sure this is the majority of the information I have collected. Basically, I feel like Fivebots's friend took advantage of having an addition account and capable of using it for his own advantage. I feel it is only fair to look into the specific posts over this to ensure Fivebots's was not just thrown into a very overwhelming report because he trusted someone....

Thanks for those reading and I am pretty sure this is the only thing I had to add


​

 

So apparently Australian Prod was made for Fivebots by someone else, meaning this account was accessed by someone else. The accounts Dylanisme and Fivebots have not actually done anything wrong themselves besides being associated with Australian Prod. I also checked the IPs and it seems that there were two different locations accessing this account. So other than sharing accounts, I can't find anything else that Fivebots has done wrong. However, I want some opinions from other mods.

 

Thanks Lazy

 

^^^ I concede to Roary above. I doubt he will be able to do that.

The truth always comes out!

 

Indeed, anywho we appreciate your input nevertheless.