New Signature, which one looks better?

Honest opinions please!




​

 

The difference between the two is very minor, I'd say the second one is better as the light texture over the text makes it more interesting.

OT: The graphic shop text and your contact details text looks very low quality (pixelated) and oversharpened otherwise its pretty good. I'd maybe decrease the intensity of the light on the right side as it draws away from the text and forms a focal in an unwanted place.

 

The second one looks nice, but honestly they don't differ much.

 

Thanks guys, working on them again when I got internet;D

 

I like the second one better, but they both look good.

 

Second one looks better because of the lighting, but if you didn't tell me that they were different i wouldn't know

 

The second one looks low quality because of the texture over it.

 

took me about 10 mins to find out what the difference between the two was...................................................................



go with the first...

 

In my opinion the first signature's color are better than the second one's

 

Hard to see the difference, but i think the 2nd looks better.

 

Thank's for all the responses. It won't be of any help anymore ;< ( restricted access to signature...

 

I'd say the second one

 

I would take the 2nd one

 

Thank's for the opinions guys!

 

2nd one looks nicer.

 

Thank you

 

I would go with the second one, first one is too "clean" for me, and the render also compliments the lighting too.
I'd still take a look at the icon's you've used though - they're low quality and don't help the finish of your signature at all.

 

Thank's for the opinion ;> will take these tips into my new signature I'm currently working on.

 

I don't like your current one, the 'explosion' looks cheap and the colours are horrible, I think the second blue one in this thread is much better.