Photo manipulation by me // Rate

So, I know this isn't the best, but I was just getting some practice in with masking, and using the clone stamp tool. I would like you guys to let me know what you think anyway, even though I personally don't think it's all that great, lol. Enjoy!
(I know the trees I put in are green and the trees in the photo are reddish-brown, so don't tell me the colors are off, lol... and where I broke the bridge, it's a little sloppy in that area too.)

Original image --

My work --

 

Colors are a bit weird, especially since the trees on the buildings are a strong green, but all others are red/brown. The trees can also be blended a little better.

Keep in mind direction of light, and REFLECTIONS. YOu have trees on buildings, but not showing up in the shadow/reflection of the water.

The bridge manip is pretty decent. Could use a little better blending on the fall one, and can use a little more disaster effects (hanging cables and stuff would be a nice touch)

 

I told you not to worry about the colors on the trees because i know they are off, lol... But anyways, very well said man. I absolutely love good feedback... But I accidentally saved while the layers were merged, so i can't change anything now, but tips are always appreciated. Thanks man.

 

i think a more grungy feel would be nice. Cracked windows/buildings. the roads "bend" where its cracking is kinda blurry too :/

 

Not bad. Not bad at all if you're not experienced with masking.

 

I'm really not, lol....

 

Wow really good for someone just learning masking this is sick, do more

 

Thanks man.. And im for sure doing more. I got a lot more done, idk if you've seen those... But i'll link my portfolio in here in a bit, when i get all my photo manipulations on there.

 

I think it's good yeah, I think it could either do with a little less exposure or desaturated a little, but other than that I like it.

You shouldn't really merge layers using adjustment layers should make it slightly easier.

Well done

 

Shrub looks a little dodgey on the buildings, but other than that, it looks really boss.

 

Thanks for all the feedback, guys... It's helps me out a lot... Even though this isn't the best piece to get it on, since I wasn't able to finish due to some saving issues.... But anyway, i'm glad you took the time to let me know what you think, so thanks.