Scammed by Plethora

Link to scammer's Sythe profile: http://www.sythe.org/members/plethora-358157.html

It was supposed to be $24 for a UC Grey Gelert on neopets.
My payment was sent, no pet was received and no further contact.

I know I'm an idiot for going through with the scam, and I should've seen it coming and been more cautious, but hopefully this will stop the user from committing more scams to other users.
I'm fairly certain it was a scam, because Plethora has not responded to me at all (while still wandering around the forum) since I sent the payment.

Screenshots:

http://i50.tinypic.com/2wc01s6.png
http://i46.tinypic.com/ok69i1.png

Hopefully I did this right?

 

Banned. Sorry for your loss. You can dispute the payment with paypal if you never received what you paid for and hopefully get your money back.

Good luck.