Chaotic Maul or Rapier?

Hey guys, I am currently 76 dungeon and I am very unsure on my weapon choice. I plan to pk with which ever weapon I choose, but it would be helpful if you guys give feedback on which one I should get. Thanks!

 

Rapier

 

Rapier

 

Rapier no doubt but you wont have enough tokens at 80 dung lol a few more level i believe or was it 88 dung for 200k tokens not sure tbh but yh

 

87-88 Dung is when you can get your SECOND chaotic. GJ.

I would get a Rapier unless you are very comfortable PK'ing. A lot of people have trouble finding good fights when they use Maul, and there is the higher possibility of getting KO'd by a venge combo when you are using maul as well.

 

I'd suggest Rapier first since it's useful for other things as well (Slayer, Bossing, etc)

If you have the time to get another weapon, then I suggest Chaotic Maul

 

Thanks everyone! So far Rapier(5) > (0)Maul!

 

There's also a massive thread about this, I think in the Runescape General area. It was created to try to help people decide so they don't have to ask this question XD

 

Bro, they both kick ass. It totally depends on what type of pking you like to do. Personally, if your pking at edge with venge, the chaotic maul will wreck. It hits huge, and all you need is two 500+ hits and their usually done. The downside of this is the recoil and vengeance. I have died so many times because they cast vengeance right before I attack with maul, and end up killing myself. I actually lost my maul because I had an intense death match with an enemy and I rushed into edgeville to kill him, forgetting to put protect item on, got claw rushed.

On the other hand the rapier is good for all around and for pking as well. Basically if you like pking with a whip, you will love rapier because it hits even harder and more consistently. Personally I like them both but the rapier wins for me because I like to hybrid. Plus when I do want to pk at edgeville, you cant go wrong with Rapier/korasi combo. Low risk and huge damage output.

 

Oh, thanks, I had no idea (pointing out the obvious) Looking into it right after I finish writing this

 

As silly as said, wrong place buddy

But, if you're looking to just PK with it, maul.
However, if you want to PvM and PK a bit, go for the rapier.

 

Please read the stickies before posting. Thanks

http://sythe.org/showthread.php?t=1122863