I would go to 43 prayer, personally. It doesn't take too terribly long, but the added protect prayers if you fight someone who uses them and Ultimate Strength can boost you max hit by almost 3 in some cases. And if you fight other pures with 1 prayer, you can really piss them off :)
That's interesting... I'm f2p, and my total level is around 900. I've gotten decent drops, but sometimes it's complete shit. I don't think there's any great correlation.