• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Non-staff verifiers.

Heidy
I just want to say now there is going to be abuse by sellers of crappy unverified guides and/or the verifiers themselves getting every guide on the site for free.

It can't be stopped currently.

My question is, is there a solution we can think up of getting rid of the possibility of abuse as much as possible without wiping the entire section out. Wiping it out, I wouldn't shed a tear but do think that is drastic.

Tbh most of the xfer guides that are verified are almost exactly the same.....
they need to sort out people who are selling the exact same guide as someone else.
 
No they can't. Their guide will not be deemed Verified unless it was verified by one of the officials..

I guess you didn't get the gist of what I was saying. Anyone can confirm that a guide works, but only official guide verifiers can actually verify it so that you can be put into the Verified Guides section and be able to put Verified in the title.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Detective
Heidy
Just to show how feeble the selection system is, I decided to look up imagination (however it's spelled).

A ban request will be in shortly.
 
Just to show how feeble the selection system is, I decided to look up imagination (however it's spelled).

A ban request will be in shortly.

What did he do? And what do you mean by "look up". Like, look him up in the phone book?
 
Sythe Awards 2012 Winner
Sythe Awards 2010 Winner
Gohan has AIDS
Discord Verified
Discord Voice
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Rust Player
Shitting Rainbow
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Detective
Top Striker
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
Sythe Awards 2010 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Heidy
Not sure if srs or just newfag...
That was Pimp.

Damn he messed up bad.

+1 Sin
 
Personally the only verifiers should be staff members. Don't even dare saying "They spend their time making sure the guide works" They are getting the guide for FREE, allowed to use it when ever they want too. They just can't leak or resell it. I have nothing wrong with this idea though I just think they should give it to trusted members.
 
I honestly don't see a problem with making an official guide verifier rank.
 
Personally, if you want the mods to have a little less time, I'd give the responsibilities to certain, ex-mods/admins, OMM's or UE's.
 
Former OMM
Pool Shark
Detective
Two Factor Authentication User
Nitro Booster
In Memory of Jon
Rio 2016
Community Participant
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Got anything else to bitch about?

Pen selected them and I don't see too many people complaining.

I'm just glad to have more verifiers, makes the guide section a little bit better.
Too bad for that Imagination kid though.

When I first suggested this idea, I thought about all the pros and cons. The pros being: mods have one less thing to worry about, trusted members get to verify, and we'll get rid of ripped guides.

If we're going to choose non-staff verifiers, we need to do background checks on anybody who's chosen to be one. I mean, look at this Imagination dude. He was a member of HackForums and he was wanting to sell his Sythe account there and purchase MSN bombers.

All I'm saying is to pick someone who everyone knows and to actually check the person before selecting them.
 
Former OMM
Pool Shark
Detective
Two Factor Authentication User
Nitro Booster
In Memory of Jon
Rio 2016
Community Participant
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Oh, and you can't trust a UE with this job. No offense to all the smart User Educators on this site, but they haven't proven anything to be trusted with this position. The User Educator rank is there to educate others on topics other than Runescape.
 
Too bad for that Imagination kid though.

When I first suggested this idea, I thought about all the pros and cons. The pros being: mods have one less thing to worry about, trusted members get to verify, and we'll get rid of ripped guides.

If we're going to choose non-staff verifiers, we need to do background checks on anybody who's chosen to be one. I mean, look at this Imagination dude. He was a member of HackForums and he was wanting to sell his Sythe account there and purchase MSN bombers.

All I'm saying is to pick someone who everyone knows and to actually check the person before selecting them.

The only valid reason out of those for banning him was the selling of his sythe account.
 
personally I like the fact that Pen has picked out more people to verify. I hope that these non-staff verifiers will do a better job then some of the staff verifiers that I have seen in the past.
 
Former OMM
Pool Shark
Detective
Two Factor Authentication User
Nitro Booster
In Memory of Jon
Rio 2016
Community Participant
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
The only valid reason out of those for banning him was the selling of his sythe account.
Either way, the staff needs to check everyone out before giving them a duty to do on Sythe. It's the same thing as selecting a mod, you need to check their background, and see if can REALLY be trusted.
 
Personally, if you want the mods to have a little less time, I'd give the responsibilities to certain, ex-mods/admins, OMM's or UE's.

I like how a UE suggests that UE's should be able to verify guides.

Anyway, one, quite obviously well thought out choice for a guide verifier, has already been banned, guide verifiers are doing a somewhat important job, please try and pick one that will last more than a few hours/days in the future.
 
I like how a UE suggests that UE's should be able to verify guides.

Anyway, one, quite obviously well thought out choice for a guide verifier, has already been banned, guide verifiers are doing a somewhat important job, please try and pick one that will last more than a few hours/days in the future.

I like how you said that as if only suggested UEs could verify guides.
I was simply stating there are other ranked people on the forum, with trust, and could help out others too. Just because I happen to be an UE, I can't suggest idea's for them? The main point in my arguement was to only make the rank available for someone with some means of experience, as I stated OMMs, Ex-admins/mods UE's, generally have trust.


I didn't even say that all UE's/ex admin/mods and OMM's WILL be guide verifiers, I said that give to various people. Personally, I wouldn't want to be a guide verifier. If mods need help I would just prefer people such as UE's, OMM's Ex admins/Mods, rather than someone who has limited trust on the forum. I'm not saying the current verifiers are not trustworthy, infact they are extreamly trusted. It's just for future reference for allowing future guide verifiers I was suggesting.
 
The only valid reason out of those for banning him was the selling of his sythe account.

only problem is there he was selling his account on a hacker forum that if someone bought, the purchaser would be a guide verifier, sending files through msn/email back and forth, and could really do some serious damage to a lot of member and cause problems in the long run.

to add to hahanerd's extra notes. we should also look at there activity. if the person is on every couple days, then the person would never be verifying guides. also to not just look at high post counts due to the fact many people should spam there way up, there should also be a join date requirement (at last 6, 8, 10, etc months on sythe) no sure if that's already intact.
 
Back
Top