• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

The Existence of God

  • Thread starter Thread starter Skilling not Killing
  • Start date Start date

Does God Exist?

  • Yes

    Votes: 990 57.3%
  • No

    Votes: 739 42.7%

  • Total voters
    1,729
Status
Not open for further replies.
Jesse I'm not referring to 9/11 I know its a conspiracy but there are actually people out there who do horrible acts in the name of Allah, well that doesn't mean the whole book is bad but it raises the question, what did they read in that book that made them justify this? I do actually know some people in real life who killed people in the name of Allah, some have gone to jail and some didn't but there are still many out there and more will rise to "Purify the world of infidels". Even if Quran had no bad verses or scriptures in it, it's still a book which has no decent proof to back it up. I wouldn't follow a religion just because it has no bad intentions in it, I would follow a religion if I'm convinced by proof or actual appearance of god/miracle to me while I'm with some people so I know I'm not hallucinating, after all he is all knowing and all powerful and don't tell me 'the purpose of religion is to have faith' well by that you mean Believe in the book even though you have no proof, you would be rewarded? I don't think so.



Stop contradicting yourself. "I'm not saying yada yada" then you go and say it. "Bottom line" is that everyone is always looking for excuses to do something stupid. Judaism had it's chance when it first came around, so did Christianity. Now we live in a more modern and expanded world which of course makes the newest religion have more problems because it's in a more complex time. The people cutting heads off? Do you even know why the justify it with god? Without saying it's god's will, no one will follow them except psycho's. But put the word god in there and you'll raise the attention of the followers of that religion, and the people who want to disprove that religion.

It never is an act of religion. Never.
 
Jεsse;3565022 said:
Stop contradicting yourself. "I'm not saying yada yada" then you go and say it. "Bottom line" is that everyone is always looking for excuses to do something stupid. Judaism had it's chance when it first came around, so did Christianity. Now we live in a more modern and expanded world which of course makes the newest religion have more problems because it's in a more complex time. The people cutting heads off? Do you even know why the justify it with god? Without saying it's god's will, no one will follow them except psycho's. But put the word god in there and you'll raise the attention of the followers of that religion, and the people who want to disprove that religion.

It never is an act of religion. Never.

Lol to religious people it is, for the normal people who are getting their head chopped off it isn't.

Anyways what are you trying to prove/say?
 
Quoted straight from my theology book...

Proofs for the Existence of God

St. Thomas Aquinas (ca 1225-1274), known as a doctor of the Church, developed the following five proofs (quinque viae) for the existence of God.

1. Life is in motion. For life to be in motion, there must have been a "first mover" to get everything going. That mover is God.

2. An egg cannot just cause itself to be an egg. There must be cause outside the egg (in other words, a rooster and a hen!) that causes it to be an egg. Likewise there must be a first cause outside all creation that caused creation to come into existence, and that first cause is God.

3. For the possibility of everything else to exist, by necessity there had to be something in existence first. This is something we call God.

4. There is something we call truest and best against which we measure everything else that is true and good. This something isn't just an abstract concept but is God.

5. The order of nature isn't just a happy accident. An intelligent being exists to direct all things to their natural ened, and this being we call God.

These are not scientific proofs, but they are arguments based on philosophical reason. Saint Thomas Aquinas is trying to let us know that something greater than humankind must have set creation in motion. This is something we call God, because by definiton God is greater than anything else we can imagine.

Food for thought?..
 
1. Life is in motion. For life to be in motion, there must have been a "first mover" to get everything going. That mover is God.
Whilst I agree the very first origins of life is unknown, presuming it came from God is an Argument From Ignorance - "I don't know how life came into existence, so God did it." There are other, more plausible theories.

2. An egg cannot just cause itself to be an egg. There must be cause outside the egg (in other words, a rooster and a hen!) that causes it to be an egg. Likewise there must be a first cause outside all creation that caused creation to come into existence, and that first cause is God.
First point is true. If there must be a first cause outside all creation that caused creation to come into existence, then what made God?

3. For the possibility of everything else to exist, by necessity there had to be something in existence first. This is something we call God.
Existence exists. It has no beginning, no end. If existence didn't exist at point, God wouldn't exist either as existence would be inexistent. This, however, is another Argument from Ignorance - "I don't know how everything came into being, so God did it".

4. There is something we call truest and best against which we measure everything else that is true and good. This something isn't just an abstract concept but is God.
Incorrect, there's no universal codex for truest and best, right or wrong, only each individual persons perspective and feelings on the topic.

5. The order of nature isn't just a happy accident. An intelligent being exists to direct all things to their natural ened, and this being we call God.
No, the order of nature isn't a just a happy accident, it's billions of years of genetic mutations within genes/DNA for countless of generations that made the order of nature.

Basically, this is how his arguments goes:
1) Insert logical statement.
2) ???
3) God did it.

Number 2 represents the gap of information that links it all to God. But hey, you've still provided better arguments than any of Creationist in this thread so far.
 
Well, obviously to know it's the Easter bunny, you'd have to PHYSICALLY see him. So before you make sarcastic posts. Read my fucking post! I said I experienced him spiritually.

Edit: How the fuck would you experience the Easter bunny?

Edit #2: Before you act smart, "I" is ALWAYS capitalised, and "your" in that statement should be "you're", so please. Before making sarcastic posts to make me look like an idiot, make them grammatically correct.

Alright asshole, if you're going to be a douche about grammar at least make sure you have it down.

Example of your mistake:
So before you make sarcastic posts.
Incomplete sentence.



Ass.
 
God can be real, from a point of view. But when you over look it all, it seems like you can question yourself into being anti-religious. I personally believe in him, but I guess we all have to wait until we die.
 
religion=fear , honestly the bible and organized religion should have been banished years ago , when we were declared our independence and the articles of confederation came into affect because then we wouldn't need religion to control our people. The bible was the first form of government. religion is tradition, but i guess we all have to believe in something. I've never known anyone who walks around and says " I dont believe in God, but I don't trust science either" you would be lost.
 
i dont have religous thoughts
 
I believe in A god.. But as for which religion I follow I am undecided. I suppose I can be considered Eastern Orthodox as I attend an Eastern Orthodox church, but I only attend because of my parents =S
 
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
I'm Christian, so yeah, I believe in God :).

Why do you believe in God?

I believe in A god.. But as for which religion I follow I am undecided. I suppose I can be considered Eastern Orthodox as I attend an Eastern Orthodox church, but I only attend because of my parents =S

While I credit you for not tagging along by a particular group of delusional followers, Why do you believe in God?
 
Shredderbeam, I completely agree with you, with all the you need to have evidence. I mean God is a strength for people who are desperate.
So the belief of god has done a lot of good. :)
I'm not saying it's true, but I'm also not saying its false.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top