- Joined
- Sep 17, 2015
- Sythe Gold
- 902
- Messages
- 5,003
- Discord Unique ID
- 171517906276843520
- Discord Username
- FuukinAndy #6867
...
Last edited:
It's provable given that you believe in what your senses tell you. You're assuming what they tell you is truth. So...yeah. That scenario doesn't change that.
Everything that the Meditator has accepted as most true he has come to learn from or through his senses. He acknowledges that sometimes the senses can deceive, but only with respect to objects that are very small or far away, and that our sensory knowledge on the whole is quite sturdy. The Meditator acknowledges that insane people might be more deceived, but that he is clearly not one of them and needn't worry himself about that.
The argument isn't necessarily that religion is true or right. The argument is that religion is equal to science in that both are assuming you can believe your senses or all the things religious people think.
The argument isn't to say that our senses aren't reliable, it's to say that we assume we can rely on them and base everything on that assumption. And since science is therefore based on a assumption, it is no better than religion. (I'm glad you realized why his argument couldn't hold against this as well)
Also I'm on your guys' side here. I'm trying to beat this too.
Science is proven or disproven under the bracket of the assumption that you can trust your senses.
So no matter what, science is an assumption just like religion is. No matter how you describe science and religion, it doesn't much matter because both are assumptions and are therefore on an equal footing.
Science is proven or disproven under the bracket of the assumption that you can trust your senses.
Thank you for responding, but based on your response it is easy to see you don't understand the argument/problem I'm trying to solve here. You're attitude is not one I want to participate with either. Looking for a productive conversation. Thanks.
It's not an assumption though, it's a fact. You can't do violent surgery on the meaning of words to produce what you want. Saying that we're assuming that we can rely on our senses is like saying we are assuming there is something that exists. You don't assume undeniable statements, they are undeniable for a reason, the very requirements to make a denial force you to first accept them. You can't assume undeniable things, that's a contradiction in terms, the very fact that it is undeniable proves it truth-hood, and something that is proven in that respect cannot be defined as an assumption without some severe surgery to its definition.The argument isn't to say that our senses aren't reliable, it's to say that we assume we can rely on them and base everything on that assumption. And since science is therefore based on a assumption, it is no better than religion. (I'm glad you realized why his argument couldn't hold against this as well)
Also I'm on your guys' side here. I'm trying to beat this too.
Your senses are of course an assumption. They are an assumption we all have to live with and don't care much about, but an assumption nonetheless.
Can you define assumption?
All of the examples you listed are interpreted by our senses. All of these things we assume we know based on our trust in our senses. We can only comprehend these things because we interpret them with our senses
Eh?? You can't sense quantum mechanics, it's literally on the atomic level.
These measurements and experiments are taken with highly precise and objective tools for the sole reason that our senses aren't sharp or reliable enough to measure the results.
I agree with your first point. I think this is a pretty pointless argument because it can't be beat, but is also kinda stupid IMO. Just wanted to see if someone could beat it so it didn't bug me. Apparently not. So I'm done with it.
You obviously don't understand the argument I described. Read it before you reply lol.
Case closed, seen enough to know it can't be beat or I'm wasting my time trying to get people to understand the concept.
Both require you to believe what your senses are telling you to be true.
The argument is taken to the next level, to interpret them results you rely on your senses, which are taken on the assumption of being true.
Hence, there's no foundation for a debate.